mail
PRESS RELEASE (2)

BURNHAM MUST NOT HAND CONTROL OF BRITAIN’S CARBON TAXES TO BRUSSELS, WARNS NEW PROSPERITY INSTITUTE PAPER

Decorative arrow

Ahead of Andy Burnham’s EU summit in Brussels this Friday, a new Prosperity Institute paper warns that linking Britain’s Emissions Trading Scheme to the EU will drive up energy costs and undermine British industry.

The Prime Minister will meet Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission, and António Costa, President of the European Council, on 20 November for the second UK-EU summit, where emissions trading is among the agreements under discussion. 

Reports suggest Britain and the EU are preparing to link their respective Emissions Trading Schemes, paving the way for reciprocal exemptions from their Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanisms. 

A new paper from the Prosperity Institute, “Not Zero: How Green Taxes Have Put British Energy Bills in the Red”, warns that linking the two carbon markets risks doing the opposite.

The research shows that alignment would push British carbon prices towards higher EU levels, raising costs for electricity generation and energy-intensive businesses. 

SAVINGS FOR HOUSEHOLDS

It finds that abolishing the main rates of the Climate Change Levy, Carbon Price Support and UK ETS would reduce government receipts by around £4.2 billion a year, but cut costs to energy users by approximately £7.3 billion annually.

Households would save around £1.8 billion through the abolition of the ETS and Carbon Price Support, including approximately £60 directly from annual household energy bills. Businesses and the public sector would receive a further £5.6 billion of relief.

Taken together, the paper estimates that the savings would be equivalent to more than £250 per household each year through lower energy bills and lower costs throughout the economy.

Endorsing the paper, Andrew Griffith MP, Shadow Chancellor of the Exchequer, said:

“Ever-higher carbon taxes risk making Britain less competitive at a time when stronger economic growth is badly needed. This new report highlights how they have destroyed jobs and negatively impacted Britain’s competitiveness, investment and growth. Instead of crawling back to the EU and handing over control of carbon taxes and energy prices, the Government should be taking advantage of our Brexit freedoms to cut costs. 

“At a time when Britain is struggling to accelerate growth, Conservatives have set out a Cheap Power Plan that will lower bills for households and businesses. As this report shows, cheaper energy and not carbon taxes are the way forward.”

Andrew Bowie MP, Shadow Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero, said:

“You cannot tax your way to prosperity. As this new report from the Prosperity Institute shows, carbon taxes are making energy more expensive for families, manufacturers and businesses across the country.

“Cheap and abundant energy is the lifeblood of the modern economy and Britain should have a tax regime which makes it competitive for businesses and households to generate and purchase the energy they need to keep the lights on and keep Britain’s economy growing.

“If Britain is serious about growth, jobs and energy security, we must be willing to challenge policies that make us poorer and less competitive. This report offers a roadmap to making this a reality once again.”

Britain’s productive economy has borne a disproportionate share of the burden from energy taxes. The paper finds that in 2023, energy taxes were equivalent to 6.3 per cent of GVA in transport, 3.8 per cent in agriculture and 1.4 per cent in manufacturing, compared with just 0.3 per cent across most service industries.

This has coincided with a dramatic decline in British energy consumption. Overall energy use has fallen by more than 20 per cent since its 2005 peak, while industrial energy consumption has almost halved since 2003.

Manufacturing has grown at only 65 per cent of the rate of the economy as a whole, despite productivity in the sector standing at 121 per cent of the national average.

The Rt Hon Robert Jenrick MP, Reform UK Treasury Spokesman, said:

“Reform UK has consistently opposed Net Zero zealotry of both parties. This new report from the Prosperity Institute demonstrates just how hard carbon taxes are hitting households and industry.

“As I laid out in our Economic Rescue Plan, we’d scrap them and cut bills for families and businesses.”

Rather than delivering further carbon-tax alignment with Brussels, the paper argues that Britain should use its freedom to pursue cheaper energy.

It recommends that the Government:

  • Abolish the UK Emissions Trading Scheme.
  • Bring forward the planned abolition of Carbon Price Support.
  • Abolish the main rates of the Climate Change Levy.
  • Reject UK-EU ETS linkage and retain national control over carbon pricing.
  • Reconsider deeper alignment with EU energy policy where it would increase costs or constrain Britain’s ability to pursue cheaper energy.

The report argues that the Government should reject the claim that ETS linkage is necessary to protect Britain from the EU’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism.

Its modelling estimates savings for British energy users from abolishing the UK ETS of £19.8 billion between 2026 and 2034, compared with £5.4 billion of additional CBAM costs under its central scenario. Even under its higher estimate for CBAM costs, the paper finds that Britain would remain at least £10.4 billion better off over the period by abolishing the ETS rather than linking it with the EU system.

Richard Tice MP, Deputy Leader of Reform UK, said:

“Britain once built things the rest of the world wanted to buy. Today, industries like steel and manufacturing are being squeezed by energy costs while investment goes elsewhere. As David Turver’s report shows, carbon taxes are weakening our competitiveness and standing in the way of reindustrialisation. If we want more British jobs and a growing economy, we need cheap, plentiful energy once again.

“Yet rather than addressing these concerns, the Government wants to increase British energy costs and hand control of them to the EU. That would leave British businesses and households at the mercy of carbon prices set in Brussels, pushing already sky-high energy costs even higher.

“At a time when we should be using national independence to dismantle the carbon tax regime, and remove policy costs to make Britain more competitive, this report proves closer alignment with the EU would entrench the very policies that caused Britain’s industrial decline.”

At a summit ostensibly designed to lower costs for British households and businesses, the Prosperity Institute argues that the Prime Minister should not sign Britain up to an arrangement that risks making the energy used by those same households and businesses more expensive.

Rather than handing greater influence over British carbon prices to Brussels, Britain should use its post-Brexit freedom to cut carbon taxes, bring down energy bills and make the country a more competitive place to manufacture, invest and grow.

[ENDS]

Notes to the editor

The Prosperity Institute is a non-party political think-tank which advocates for policies and practices that promote prosperity in the United Kingdom and beyond.

Any questions or press inquiries should be sent to joseph.dinnage@prosperity.com / 07413 016026.